Purchase tax on an apartment whose construction is not finished: shell apartments, missing finishing works and buildings under construction

14 November 2026 · Real estate taxation

Purchase tax on an apartment whose construction is not finished: shell apartments, missing finishing works and buildings under construction

Purchase tax on a residential apartment is calculated in brackets, and a right in real estate that is not a residential apartment is taxed at a flat rate. An apartment whose construction is not finished may be a residential apartment for purchase tax, depending on its condition on the day of purchase, on the buyer’s intention, and on whether the seller passed to the buyer an undertaking to complete the construction.

The definition in section 9(c) of the Law

The Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) Law, 1963 (the “Law”) imposes purchase tax in section 9. A right in real estate that is not a residential apartment is taxed at a flat rate under regulation 2 of the Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) (Purchase Tax) Regulations, 1974, and a residential apartment is taxed in brackets that depend on the type of buyer and the number of apartments the buyer owns. The definition of a residential apartment for purchase tax is wider than the definition in section 1 of the Law, which applies to betterment tax, and does not require the apartment to be intended for residence “by its nature”.

Section 9(c) of the Law, before the 2023 amendment, defined a residential apartment as “an apartment used or intended to be used for residence, including an apartment whose construction has not been completed, other than an apartment with no undertaking by the seller to complete the construction”. In Civil Appeal 278/84 Friedman v. Betterment Tax Director (10 August 1987) the Supreme Court held that for purchase tax, whether an apartment is intended for residence is tested by two cumulative tests: an objective test of potential for residence, even in a property that is not fit to live in at present, and a subjective test of the buyer’s intention to live in it. The Economic Efficiency Law (Legislative Amendments for Achieving Budget Targets for the 2023 and 2024 Budget Years), 2023, added to the definition “a shell apartment intended to be used for residence”, and defined a shell apartment as an apartment, in a building intended for residence, whose construction has not been completed and with no undertaking by the seller to complete the construction, provided that the construction of the apartment’s external walls has been completed. The amendment applies to purchases from 1 January 2024.

Case law on betterment tax also helps decide whether a property is an apartment. In Appeal (Tel Aviv) 28079-10-15 Ma’ayan v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (19 July 2020) the committee held that a property in a residential building, connected to the electricity and water networks, may be a residential apartment even when facilities are missing, if they can easily be installed. The Supreme Court dismissed the Director’s appeal in the same case by a majority (Civil Appeal 6107/20, 19 July 2022).

An apartment with missing finishing works

In Appeal (Tel Aviv) 39040-09-22 Krasny v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (16 March 2025) the committee held that the apartment did not meet the objective test: the ceiling was bare concrete, there was no final flooring, kitchen, internal partitions or shower, and it was not permanently connected to electricity and water. The municipality had been told that it was a shell apartment not fit for residence.

In Appeal 15365-08-24 Tousia-Cohen v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (15 September 2026) (“Tousia-Cohen”) a couple bought an apartment on HaBroshim Street in Ramat HaSharon on 20 December 2022 for NIS 9,450,557. The apartment was built by the landowners themselves, under a residential building permit and an agreement with a contractor for construction to turnkey stage, and the sellers sold it as is. The buyers argued that they received an unfinished apartment, that completing it cost more than NIS 580,000 and that they rented elsewhere for about eight months, and they reported purchase tax of 6% under regulation 2(1) of the Purchase Tax Regulations. The Director classified the apartment as a residential apartment and, since it was not the buyers’ only apartment, assessed tax at 8% and 10%.

The Lod appeals committee dismissed the appeal. The buyers moved into the apartment in October 2023, so the subjective test was met. The building had a Form 4 and a completion certificate, the apartment was charged municipal tax as a residence from February 2022 and received an exemption as an empty property, and it was connected to the utilities. Photographs taken by a municipal inspector eight days after signing, and an expert opinion the buyers themselves filed in a claim against the contractor, showed a kitchen with a sink and tap, toilets, a shower, ceramic tiling, parquet, electric shutters and air conditioning. According to the committee, unfinished finishing works and construction defects do not turn an apartment into a shell apartment; otherwise every apartment undergoing a major renovation would be a building for the duration of the works. The committee also held that the sellers assigned to the buyers their rights under the construction agreement, which included an undertaking to build to turnkey stage, and that under the definition this alone is enough to classify the property as a residential apartment.

The committee rejected the argument that the sellers reported a residential apartment only to save tax, since the tax they saved was NIS 14,000. A similar ground-floor apartment in the same building was sold in January 2022 for NIS 8,250,000, less than the buyers paid, and both parties reported it as a residential apartment. The buyers attached to their affidavit the settlement agreement with the contractor and not the expert opinion, and objected to the Director’s request to inspect the court file of the claim. The committee regarded this as a significant lack of good faith and ordered them to pay costs of NIS 40,000.

A building under construction and the seller’s undertaking

Under section 9(c) of the Law, an apartment whose construction has not been completed is a residential apartment for purchase tax if it comes with “an undertaking by the seller to complete the construction”. A person who buys an apartment off plan from a developer buys a residential apartment, and a person who buys a building shell with no construction contract and completes the construction alone does not. The question arises when the seller is not a developer and passes to the buyer the seller’s rights under a contract with a contractor. In Appeal (Tel Aviv) 27652-05-24 Sharvit v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Hadera (22 September 2026) (“Sharvit”) the Tel Aviv appeals committee reviewed the decisions on the question, and the table sets them out.

Decision The transaction Holding on the undertaking
Appeal 48493-05-15 Akerman (Tel Aviv, 21 May 2017) The sellers’ rights under an agreement with a building contractor were assigned to the buyers Majority: there is no undertaking by the seller personally, so there is no undertaking by the seller. The appeal was decided on another issue, a purchase group
Appeal 59441-10-17 Lesman (Central-Lod, 27 April 2020) A gift of rights in land subject to a combination deal with a developer There is an undertaking by the seller if the seller holds an enforceable third-party undertaking to complete the construction and passes it to the buyer. On the Supreme Court’s recommendation the appellants withdrew their appeal (Civil Appeal 4278/20, 22 November 2021)
Appeal 2651-05-23 Michaeli (Central-Lod, 12 January 2026) Stepping into the shoes of a seller who had ordered construction services from a contractor, before construction began and before the apartments were identified Not a residential apartment, because the buyer had to act alone to obtain a finished apartment. The appeal was allowed, and an appeal against the decision is pending
Sharvit (Tel Aviv, 22 September 2026) A two-family house in Caesarea at the plastering stage, with assignment of the construction contract to contractors owned by the sellers’ fathers There is an undertaking by the seller, and residential apartments were bought

In Sharvit two brothers and their partners bought in November 2022 the two units of the house for NIS 5.5 million each, stepped into the sellers’ shoes in the construction contract, and undertook to pay the contractors NIS 1 million already accrued and NIS 1 million to complete the construction. The sale agreements stated that the sellers were not responsible for the contractors’ obligations, and the buyers therefore argued that there was no undertaking by the seller and that the purchase tax was 5% under regulation 2 of the Purchase Tax Regulations. The committee unanimously dismissed the appeal, relying on several circumstances: the construction contract obliged the contractors to complete the construction up to Form 4 and permanent connection to the utilities; the construction was at the plastering stage inside and out; the sale agreements and the construction contract were bound up with each other, for example in that the buyers could not cancel the construction contract before they finished paying the sellers; of about NIS 15 million the buyers paid, NIS 14.5 million went to the sellers and only half a million to the contractor; the contractors were owned by the sellers’ fathers; and only about 19 months passed between the sellers’ purchase of the land and the sale. The chair, Judge H. Kirsch, distinguished the case from Michaeli. Committee member CPA Zvi Friedman, who had been in the majority in Akerman, wrote that following Civil Appeal 4278/20 the wider reading in Lesman should be adopted. No costs were ordered, because of the complexity of the question.

A neutral reading of the definition

In Sharvit the committee noted that because of the changes in purchase tax rates, classifying a property as a residential apartment saves tax for one buyer and increases it for another, especially for expensive properties, so the definition should be read neutrally, with no tendency either to ease or to tighten.

Further reading

Sources

Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) Law, 1963, sections 1 and 9 · Economic Efficiency Law (Legislative Amendments for Achieving Budget Targets for the 2023 and 2024 Budget Years), 2023 · Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) (Purchase Tax) Regulations, 1974, regulation 2 · Civil Appeal 278/84 Friedman v. Betterment Tax Director (10 August 1987) · Appeal 48493-05-15 Akerman v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (21 May 2017) · Appeal 59441-10-17 Lesman v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Central (27 April 2020) · Appeal (Tel Aviv) 28079-10-15 Ma’ayan v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (19 July 2020) · Civil Appeal 4278/20 Lesman v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Central (22 November 2021) · Civil Appeal 6107/20 Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv v. Ma’ayan (19 July 2022) · Appeal (Tel Aviv) 39040-09-22 Krasny v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (16 March 2025) · Appeal 2651-05-23 Michaeli v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Central (12 January 2026) · Appeal 15365-08-24 Tousia-Cohen v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (15 September 2026) · Appeal (Tel Aviv) 27652-05-24 Sharvit v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Hadera (22 September 2026)

General overview only, not legal advice. Purchase tax rates and case law are updated from time to time. Updated 14 November 2026.

x
סייען נגישות
הגדלת גופן
הקטנת גופן
גופן קריא
גווני אפור
גווני מונוכרום
איפוס צבעים
הקטנת תצוגה
הגדלת תצוגה
איפוס תצוגה

אתר מונגש

אנו רואים חשיבות עליונה בהנגשת אתר האינטרנט שלנו לאנשים עם מוגבלויות, וכך לאפשר לכלל האוכלוסיה להשתמש באתרנו בקלות ובנוחות. באתר זה בוצעו מגוון פעולות להנגשת האתר, הכוללות בין השאר התקנת רכיב נגישות ייעודי.

סייגי נגישות

למרות מאמצנו להנגיש את כלל הדפים באתר באופן מלא, יתכן ויתגלו חלקים באתר שאינם נגישים. במידה ואינם מסוגלים לגלוש באתר באופן אופטימלי, אנה צרו איתנו קשר

רכיב נגישות

באתר זה הותקן רכיב נגישות מתקדם, מבית all internet - בניית אתרים.רכיב זה מסייע בהנגשת האתר עבור אנשים בעלי מוגבלויות.