An apartment bought for a minor counts among the family’s apartments for purchase tax, even when a grandparent paid for it with full separation of property

14 November 2026 · Real estate taxation

An apartment bought for a minor counts among the family’s apartments for purchase tax, even when a grandparent paid for it with full separation of property

The reduced purchase tax for a single apartment is tested against all the apartments of the family unit: the buyer, the buyer’s spouse and their children under 18. A minor whose parents own an apartment and who buys an apartment of his or her own pays purchase tax at the rates for an additional apartment. In summer 2026 an appeals committee held that the rule applies even when the money came from a grandfather and the parents are barred from any use of the apartment or its income.

Purchase tax rates for a single apartment

The Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) Law, 1963 (the “Law”) provides in section 9(a) that a buyer of a right in real estate is liable to purchase tax. Section 9(c1c) sets reduced rates for buying a single residential apartment, and section 9(c1f) sets the rates for a residential apartment that is not a single apartment. Under section 9(c1c)(4)(a), a single apartment is “a residential apartment that is the buyer’s only apartment in Israel and in the Area as defined in section 16A”. A buyer who owns another residential apartment pays at the rates for an apartment that is not a single apartment, subject to the exceptions in the section, such as a buyer who sells the previous apartment within the period the Law sets.

The family unit presumption

Section 9(c1c)(4)(c) of the Law provides that a buyer and the buyer’s spouse, other than a spouse who permanently lives separately, and their children under 18, other than a married child or a child orphaned of one or both parents, are regarded as one buyer. The provision is known as the family unit presumption. All the apartments of the spouses and of their minor children are counted as the apartments of a single buyer, so an apartment bought in the name of any member of the unit is tested against the apartments of all of them. Section 49(b) of the Law contains a similar provision for the exemption from betterment tax on the sale of a single qualifying residential apartment.

The exceptions in the statute

The section excludes three cases from the family unit: a spouse who permanently lives separately, a married child, and a child orphaned of one or both parents. The orphaned child exception was added in Amendment 103 to the Law. The married child exception has been in the section from the start.

The exceptions the courts recognised for spouses

The courts added two exceptions, and both concern spouses. Under the historical baggage exception, steps a spouse took before the family unit was formed are not taken into account to deny relief to the other spouse (Tax Appeal (Be’er Sheva) 2979/97 Mor v. Betterment Tax Director, Be’er Sheva (15 July 1998); Civil Appeal 3185/03 Betterment Tax Director, Central Region v. Plam, PD 59(1) 123 (2004)). Under the separation of property exception, the presumption is rebuttable and does not apply where the spouses agreed on separation of property in a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement and the separation is applied in practice (Civil Appeal 3178/12 Shalmi v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (17 November 2014)). In Civil Appeal 4298/18 Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv v. Blank (20 April 2021) (“Blank”) the Supreme Court held that the separation of property is recognised even where the spouses live together in an apartment that belongs to one of them under the agreement.

In Shalmi, Justice Y. Danziger described the situations that justified the exception: spouses who form a family unit later in life, each owning an apartment, and spouses in a second marriage, each with assets and children of their own. In both, each spouse brings historical baggage, and the spouses usually sign a property agreement.

The purposes of the presumption

The courts attribute two purposes to the family unit presumption. The negative purpose is to prevent tax planning in which apartments used by the family are registered in the names of different family members to multiply the relief. The positive purpose is tied to the purpose of the relief itself. In Blank, Justice O. Grosskopf wrote that the main social purpose of the betterment tax exemption and of the purchase tax relief is to make it easier to buy a first home for the taxpayer to live in, and to reduce the cost of moving from one home to another. Since a family usually lives in one home, the purpose justifies limiting the relief to one apartment per family unit.

The Law does not make the relief conditional on the buyer living in the apartment. The owner of a single apartment may rent it out and rent another home with the rent, and still have the relief. The relief is for a single apartment, and not for an additional apartment held as an investment.

Minors in earlier appeals committee decisions

A purchase by a minor whose parents own an apartment came before appeals committees twice before 2026. In Appeal (Tel Aviv) 1393/01 Even Ezra v. Betterment Tax, Netanya (29 June 2003) the apartment was bought by the grandfather, and in Appeal (Tel Aviv) 62431-06-15 Hajaj v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (27 April 2017) the purchase was apparently funded by the parents. In both, the majority held that the family unit presumption applied and that the apartment was not a single apartment, and in both committee member Adv. Dan Margaliot dissented.

In Even Ezra, Judge Y. Ben Shlomo wrote that the exceptions in the section, a spouse living permanently apart and a married child, show that the legislature regarded minors as living under their parents’ roof until they come of age. In Hajaj, Judge H. Kirsch wrote that the provision is meant to ensure that the purchase tax relief is given once to each nuclear family, on the assumption that family members live together. An appeal was filed against the Hajaj decision (Civil Appeal 4677/17). On the Supreme Court’s recommendation the appellants gave notice on 4 April 2019 that they did not pursue it, and it was dismissed.

The wording of the section when the buyer is a minor

Adv. Margaliot pointed to a difficulty in the wording. The provision applies the presumption to “a buyer and the buyer’s spouse … and their children”. When the buyer is a parent, the parent’s minor children are part of the parent’s unit. When the buyer is the minor, a literal reading produces an empty group, because a minor has no children and usually no spouse. In Hajaj, Judge Kirsch found support for the wider reading in the plural word “their children”. A similar difficulty exists in section 49(b) of the Law, for the betterment tax exemption.

In Appeal 49040-09-24 Burger v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Central District (16 June 2026, released for publication on 6 July 2026) (“Burger”) the committee noted that the appellants did not raise the wording argument, and that the interpretation settled in case law and practice for decades treats the parents and their minor children as one unit, including where the minor is the buyer.

Twelve apartments in Ramat Gan

In Burger a grandfather negotiated with a developer to buy 12 apartments in a project on Rashi Street in Ramat Gan. On 18 September 2023 he signed gift agreements with 12 minors, ten of his grandchildren and two granddaughters of his partner, through their parents. To each minor he undertook to give NIS 3,541,000 to buy an apartment, and to pay all the purchase costs, including purchase tax. On 20 September 2023 the parents signed the purchase agreements on behalf of the minors, at NIS 3,541,667 per apartment. The minors belonged to four family units, and each unit owned a residential apartment before the purchase.

Under the gift agreements, the apartments are to be rented out when construction is completed, and the rent deposited in a dedicated account in each minor’s name. The parents may not use the rent or live in the apartments. From age 18 the minor may use the rent without restriction, and from age 25 may sell or mortgage the apartment. A sale before age 25 requires court approval. The agreements were sent to the Administrator General for review and approved by the Family Court in Be’er Sheva. The Real Estate Taxation Director did not dispute that the money came from the grandfather or that the agreements created a separation of property between the apartments and their income and the parents.

The minors filed self-assessments at the single apartment rates, NIS 75,768 for each buyer. The Director assessed purchase tax of NIS 283,333 for each buyer, at the rates for an apartment that is not a single apartment. The difference is NIS 207,565 per apartment, about NIS 2.49 million for the 12 apartments. The committee dismissed the appeal with no order for costs, and under the agreements the grandfather bears the tax.

Source of funds and separation of property for minors

The appellants argued that the money came from outside the family unit, and that the gift agreements, approved by the court, created a full separation of property. In their view, once Shalmi and Blank held that the presumption is rebuttable, the difference between spouses and minors is technical, and applying the presumption to minors makes it irrebuttable and discriminates against them. They also argued that the minors would lose the relief when they come of age, because any apartment they buy then would be an additional apartment.

The committee found no tax planning in the case, and held that if the negative purpose were the only purpose of the presumption, there would be no ground to apply it. In the committee’s view, the positive purpose directs the relief to a roof over the head of a person and his or her family, and buying an apartment for a minor who lives with the parents is primarily an investment. The source of the money therefore does not decide the matter: the relief is not intended for buying an apartment for a minor who lives with the parents, whether the money comes from the parents or from the grandparents. Had the appellants’ position been accepted, a purchase funded by the parents with a separation of property would also have met the conditions.

The separation of property exception was recognised because of the circumstances of adult spouses, such as a second marriage and assets owned before the marriage, and because of each spouse’s autonomy in dividing property. According to the committee, these reasons do not apply to minors living with their parents, and it is for the legislature to extend the exceptions to them. The committee added that the Director has limited ability to examine the sources of money within a family. The table sets out the distinction as the committee drew it.

Issue Spouses Minor children
Statutory exception A spouse who permanently lives separately A married child; a child orphaned of one or both parents
Historical baggage Recognised (Mor, Plam) Not decided
Separation of property under an agreement applied in practice Rebuts the presumption (Shalmi, Blank) Does not rebut the presumption (Burger)
Funding from outside the family unit Not decided Does not rebut the presumption (Even Ezra, Burger)

The committee noted that complex cases may also arise for minors, that the courts will deal with them when they come, and repeated the call on the legislature to regulate the matter.

Executive Instruction 6/2011

The Director relied on Israel Tax Authority Executive Instruction 6/2011, under which a minor’s apartment bought with money from family members or relatives is counted among the family unit’s apartments, because of the difficulty of tracing transfers of money within a family. The appellants argued that the instruction recognises that a minor can be taken out of the presumption in some cases, such as a purchase from compensation money or an inheritance. The committee held that an executive instruction does not bind the court, and that the instruction expressly states that funding by a relative does not take the apartment out of the family unit. It remarked that it was doubtful whether the instruction reflects a consistent line on minors’ apartments, and for that reason made no order for costs against the appellants.

Consequences at 18 and on a later sale

The apartment is registered in the minor’s name. When the minor turns 18 he or she leaves the parents’ family unit, and the apartment becomes his or her own apartment. An apartment the minor buys later, while still owning the first one, is not a single apartment. The committee rejected the argument that this infringes a right, and held that there is no right to a once-in-a-lifetime benefit for a person who is not among those for whom the benefit was intended.

The family unit presumption also appears in section 49(b) of the Law, for the betterment tax exemption on the sale of a single qualifying residential apartment. In Burger the committee mentioned that the question has a future effect on betterment tax, where the amounts are sometimes large.

Further reading

Sources

Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) Law, 1963, sections 9(a), 9(c1c), 9(c1f) and 49(b) · Israel Tax Authority Executive Instruction 6/2011 · Tax Appeal (Be’er Sheva) 2979/97 Mor v. Betterment Tax Director, Be’er Sheva (15 July 1998) · Appeal (Tel Aviv) 1393/01 Even Ezra v. Betterment Tax, Netanya (29 June 2003) · Civil Appeal 3185/03 Betterment Tax Director, Central Region v. Plam, PD 59(1) 123 (2004) · Civil Appeal 3178/12 Shalmi v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (17 November 2014) · Appeal (Tel Aviv) 62431-06-15 Hajaj v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (27 April 2017) · Civil Appeal 4677/17 Hajaj v. Betterment Tax Director, Tel Aviv (4 April 2019) · Civil Appeal 4298/18 Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv v. Blank (20 April 2021) · Appeal 49040-09-24 Burger v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Central District (16 June 2026)

General overview only, not legal advice. Purchase tax rates, executive instructions and case law are updated from time to time. Updated 14 November 2026.

x
סייען נגישות
הגדלת גופן
הקטנת גופן
גופן קריא
גווני אפור
גווני מונוכרום
איפוס צבעים
הקטנת תצוגה
הגדלת תצוגה
איפוס תצוגה

אתר מונגש

אנו רואים חשיבות עליונה בהנגשת אתר האינטרנט שלנו לאנשים עם מוגבלויות, וכך לאפשר לכלל האוכלוסיה להשתמש באתרנו בקלות ובנוחות. באתר זה בוצעו מגוון פעולות להנגשת האתר, הכוללות בין השאר התקנת רכיב נגישות ייעודי.

סייגי נגישות

למרות מאמצנו להנגיש את כלל הדפים באתר באופן מלא, יתכן ויתגלו חלקים באתר שאינם נגישים. במידה ואינם מסוגלים לגלוש באתר באופן אופטימלי, אנה צרו איתנו קשר

רכיב נגישות

באתר זה הותקן רכיב נגישות מתקדם, מבית all internet - בניית אתרים.רכיב זה מסייע בהנגשת האתר עבור אנשים בעלי מוגבלויות.